TP Home | About | Newsletter | Blogs |

Toupret Gras A Laquer v Sikkens Kodrin Spachtel...price performance?

An oldie but goodie…very happy user of Spachtel for external decorating. Spot on stuff.

But was just looking at prices to order some more and noticed ads for both products jumping out.

If I read right I can buy 4 x 1kg packs of the Toupret product for £39. Whereas the Spachtel is is about £30 for 900g.

I need to do the entire internal woodwork on this place and although cost is not the driver, it seems a huge differential. Just wandering on a product performance basis if there is any great difference (not used the Toupret product) …if there is not then the price performance becomes a little hard to stomach. Opinions and experiences as always would be very welcome. All the best

Are you painting doors?works great on dark colours like black.

Hi Jason, no it will be for skirtings, door casings and architraves internally. Doors in this case will be new and not require painting.

Yes have used it a lot in the recent past and I’m a total fan of the Sikkens version…not yet used the Toupret version although from what I read it is ‘generally’ the same format I think.

It is the cost comparison that causes me to scratch my head some. And that said, if the Toupret is ‘as good’ and cheaper by a factor of 400% then it strikes me as mad not to give it a go.

Certainly no complaints with the Sikkens product…far from…but the cost ration seems either a. too good to be true or b. wrong.

I suppose to say another way, is it worth to pay more than 4 x times the price for the Sikkens product…is it that much better?

1 Like

Hi, sorry missed this.

Can you not get one tub of Toupret Gras a Lacquer to satisfy yourself it is also a forgiving oil based surfacer filler product.

This is one of those special decorating moments, a keen DIY debating the finer points of a specialist filling product that so few in the trade have even heard of, let alone used. You are a welcome fanatic!

cheers

2 Likes

Yet again Andy you introduce logic and reason…yeah why didn’t I think of that!!! :slight_smile: I even have a new Spachtel tin so it’s even more logical and do-able.

In fact the listed single piece price is hardly any cheaper than a 4 pack although the supplier I saw lumped a hefty postage fee on a single intem…ironically still cheaper than the Sikkens stuff.

Yeah I love all this magic potion stuff…I feel quite disappointed these days when I have to buy a “normal” product!

Worse still, try telling a plasterer who have just re-done 6 rooms that you are going to fill over all his hard work and then sand it all down!!!..they inch crab-like towards the door before running to their van and to the hills! … I’ve actually stopped telling people now :confused:

Cheers Andy, I’m going to do as you mention and weigh it and report back.

Well I at last bought a 1kg tin of the Toupret Gras and have to say I find it much harder work than the Kodrin Spachtel.

I’m not sure I got a duff tin. Although it arrived well packed there was a lid dink. Could not see any leakage but there was no liquid on the top of the can … instructions suggested there would be. And indeed there was some crusting. Mind you the Kodrin was the same with most tins I ever bought.

I have a feeling that that might be the root of the problem but it felt nowhere near as smooth as the Kodrin. What reckon? Just a duff tin? Everyone else seems be having good experiences with it from what I read.

Also I saw in Andy’s article that Prestonett do a GL … but can I find it? Nowhere in the UK that I can see. Anyone know a supplier?

Many thanks

Try adding a few drops of boiled linseed oil to a dollop of GL.

Fascinating thread about putty here.

The one issue I’ve had is that when it arrives, it is a little too stiff to work with, almost as if it’s not fresh enough, it also has a light skin on top, and sometimes a puddle of oil on top of that. Since I always order it in cases of 1 quart containers, I usually warm in in the microwave for 30-60 seconds, then I dump it into a larger container, add some boiled linseed oil to thin it, then take my mixer to it. If heavy thinning is required I’ll use a little of the raw linseed oil too, which I assume will help retain some sort of balance to the mix.

Another resource on make your own brushing putty

1 Like

Hi Andy, what great threads … still reading the first one.

Yeah what described is precisely what I’m seeing a think … yes needs thinning. Think when it is then I should good to go.

Back off the read the entire thread :slight_smile: … as you say, an interesting read. The Yanks seem have a good few more off the shelf products than we do. Wander if they are accessible here?

Cheers